# Fish for Secret Animals Guide Use this free Fish for Secret Animals guide to track sales, costs, and time and compare net coins across runs. # Drop Chance Calculator https://fishforsecretanimals.org/drop-chance-calculator/ Enter a drop rate and number of attempts to see your chance of at least one drop or no drops. ## How to use it 1. Enter the chance for one eligible attempt as a percentage. 2. Enter how many attempts you want to model under the same conditions. 3. Read the chance of at least one drop alongside the chance of none. ## Examples - One percent across 100 attempts: Drop chance per attempt = 1, Independent attempts = 100 → Chance of at least one drop: 63.396766 %; Chance of no drops: 36.603234 %; Average drops over repeated batches: 1 - Even odds on two attempts: Drop chance per attempt = 50, Independent attempts = 2 → Chance of at least one drop: 75 %; Chance of no drops: 25 %; Average drops over repeated batches: 1 - Guaranteed rate with zero attempts: Drop chance per attempt = 100, Independent attempts = 0 → Chance of at least one drop: 0 %; Chance of no drops: 100 %; Average drops over repeated batches: 0 ## Method The complement rule gives a one-attempt miss probability of 1 minus p, where p is the entered rate divided by 100. For n independent attempts at the same rate, multiply the miss probability by itself n times to get (1 − p) raised to n. Subtract that result from 1 for at least one drop. The expected count is n times p by linearity of expectation. With zero attempts the chance of any drop and expected count are both zero. ## Limits - Supply a verified per-attempt rate or a clearly hypothetical rate. The tool has no built-in catch rates for Fish for Secret Animals. - Pity counters, changing boosts, and guaranteed rewards can violate independence or the constant-rate assumption. - Very small chances can round to zero at the displayed precision, and very large batches can round to 100%. ## FAQ Q: How does the drop chance calculator work? A: It subtracts the probability of missing every attempt from 100%. At 1% per attempt, 100 independent tries give about a 63.4% chance of at least one success. Q: Does a 1 in 100 drop rate guarantee one drop after 100 attempts? A: No. At that rate, a 100-attempt batch has about a 36.6% chance of no drop even though it averages one drop per batch over many batches. Q: How do I enter a one-in-500 drop rate? A: Enter 0.2%. Divide 1 by 500 and multiply by 100 to convert the fraction to a percentage. Q: Do misses improve the odds of my next cast? A: Under the independent model, every eligible attempt has the same input probability. A pity counter or changing game conditions would require a different model. Q: Why is the average number of drops sometimes above one? A: A batch can contain multiple successes. Expected drops count all of them, while chance of at least one counts whether the batch has any success at all. Q: Can I use this with a luck boost? A: Use the effective per-attempt rate if it is known and stays fixed throughout the batch. The calculator does not infer a rate from a luck multiplier alone. What do the drop chance calculator results mean? The free drop chance calculator models a batch of independent attempts at the percentage you enter. For example, on two attempts at 50% each, both can miss with probability 25%. That leaves a 75% chance of getting at least one drop. There is also a 25% chance of getting two, which is included in the at-least-one result. Count chances to get the catch you want For a rare catch, count only casts where that catch could have appeared under the conditions of your example. If you spend part of a trip in another area, those casts may not qualify for the same rate. If you swap bait halfway through and the rates are known to differ, compute the no-drop probability for each group separately. Multiply the two no-drop probabilities and subtract the product from 1 to find the combined chance of success, assuming the groups remain independent. Read a dry streak in context At a hypothetical 1% chance per attempt, one success per 100 attempts is the long-run average. Around 37 out of 100 independent batches of that length would return no drops under the same assumptions. The calculation can help you judge how common a dry run might be. It cannot show whether a specific rarity or boost is implemented in the game. Use a rate from a documented source when you have one, and label any guess as a scenario. Why does this page start at one percent? The default 1% and 100 attempts are teaching inputs. They illustrate why a one-in-a-hundred rate and a hundred attempts can still produce a dry run. The developer’s Secret Catch badge (https://www.roblox.com/badges/377429947809101/Secret-Catch) names the achievement without publishing an eligible attempt rate. Use the default to test the math, then enter a verified rate only when its conditions match your setup. Open the 20-attempt scenario (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/drop-chance-calculator/?chance=1&attempts=20) to see the same rate across a shorter outing. If no reliable rate is available, keep the inputs labeled as a scenario and record casts and outcomes in the fishing run log (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fishing-run-log/). --- # Payback Period Calculator https://fishforsecretanimals.org/payback-period-calculator/ Enter an upgrade cost plus both net hourly rates to see how long the extra earnings take to repay your purchase. ## How to use it 1. Enter the one-time cost of the upgrade you are evaluating. 2. Use the net hourly earnings of your current setup as the baseline. 3. Enter a trial rate or a rate you want to test for the upgraded setup. 4. Compare the payback time with how long you expect to use the upgrade. ## Examples - Recovering a 3,000-coin purchase: Upgrade cost = 3000, Current net hourly earnings = 1600, Upgraded net hourly earnings = 2200 → Estimated payback time: 5 h; Change in hourly earnings: 600 coins/h; How to read this result: Upgrade cost divided by the extra net coins earned per hour. - A paid upgrade earns the same: Upgrade cost = 1800, Current net hourly earnings = 1500, Upgraded net hourly earnings = 1500 → Estimated payback time: ; Change in hourly earnings: 0 coins/h; How to read this result: The upgrade does not pay back at these rates. - No purchase price: Upgrade cost = 0, Current net hourly earnings = 1200, Upgraded net hourly earnings = 1100 → Estimated payback time: 0 h; Change in hourly earnings: -100 coins/h; How to read this result: There is no purchase cost to recover. ## Method Subtract the current net hourly rate from the upgraded net hourly rate. The difference is the hourly benefit attributable to the upgrade under the entered assumptions. For a positive benefit, simple payback equals the one-time cost divided by extra net coins per hour. The division returns hours. A paid upgrade has no finite payback at an unchanged or lower rate. An upgrade with no cost has zero hours of cost to recover. ## Limits - The estimate assumes the difference in rates persists over the measured hours. - The calculation values coin earnings alone and omits resale proceeds and benefits that do not earn coins. ## FAQ Q: How does the payback period calculator work? A: It divides the upgrade cost by the increase in net coins per hour. A cost of 3,000 coins and a gain of 600 coins per hour imply five hours. Q: What happens when the upgraded setup earns less? A: A paid upgrade has no payback at a lower net rate. The hourly change shows how much less it earns. Q: Do I include the purchase in the upgraded hourly rate? A: Put the one-time price in the cost field. Keep the hourly rate for repeatable costs, such as bait you use while fishing. Q: Can payback time tell me if I can afford a rod? A: Payback estimates how long extra earnings take to recover the price after purchase. The savings goal tool estimates time to afford the purchase. Q: Is the payback period measured in days or hours? A: It is measured in hours spent earning at the entered rates. A five-hour payback takes five play sessions if you fish one hour per session. Q: Can I use a negative net rate? A: Yes. A loss that falls from 300 to 100 coins per hour has a 200-coin hourly benefit, even though both setups still lose coins. When would a fishing upgrade pay for itself? The free payback period calculator compares an upgrade with the setup you could keep using. If the new setup earns 2,000 coins an hour and the old one earns 1,500, only the extra 500 counts toward recovering the purchase. A price of 2,500 coins takes five hours to recover at that difference. Using the entire 2,000-coin rate would assign earnings to the upgrade that you could have made anyway. Measure both setups on the same terms Use the same rules for bait, travel, and selling when timing each run. For example, compare two rates that both include travel from the same starting point. If your current route earns 1,800 net coins per hour and the upgraded setup earns 2,100, the hourly gain is 300. If a longer trip to the upgraded spot reduces that figure to 1,950, the gain is only 150. That doubles the estimated time to recover the same purchase. Work backward from the time you will use it If a rod costs 4,800 coins and you expect to use it for eight hours before switching setups again, it would need to add 600 net coins per hour to pay for itself in that window. Use this comparison to set a target for a trial run. An estimate based on more than one session is easier to interpret when one catch accounts for much of the upgraded setup's earnings. To estimate how long it takes to collect the purchase price in the first place, use the Savings Goal Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/savings-goal-calculator/). Where do the default rates come from? The 3,000-coin price, 1,600 baseline and 2,200 trial rate are a practice scenario from the rod selection guide (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-rods/). The update needs to earn an extra 600 coins per hour to repay the price in five hours. Use the four-trip payback example (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/payback-period-calculator/?price=3000&before=2580&after=3720) to compare rates from a set of sample runs instead. The run log (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fishing-run-log/) shows how to reproduce the two rates, and how a large isolated sale can move the estimate from under three hours to over eighteen. Keep your actual run totals and the purchase price together so you can revisit the result after more trips. --- # Weighted Average Calculator https://fishforsecretanimals.org/weighted-average-calculator/ Enter up to three values and their weights to find a weighted average that accounts for different fishing session lengths. ## How to use it 1. Enter each session rate as a value and its elapsed minutes as the corresponding weight. 2. Set a row’s weight to zero if you are using fewer than three rows. 3. Read the result in the same units as your values, such as coins per hour. ## Examples - Ten-minute and fifty-minute fishing runs: First value = 4200, First weight = 10, Second value = 1800, Second weight = 50, Third value = 0, Third weight = 0 → Weighted average: 2,200; Total weight: 60; Values included: 2 - Equal weights: First value = 800, First weight = 5, Second value = 1600, Second weight = 5, Third value = 0, Third weight = 0 → Weighted average: 1,200; Total weight: 10; Values included: 2 - Include an unprofitable run: First value = -300, First weight = 20, Second value = 2100, Second weight = 40, Third value = 900, Third weight = 60 → Weighted average: 1,100; Total weight: 120; Values included: 3 ## Method Add the weights. Divide each positive weight by that total to find its share. Multiply each value by its share and sum the products. This is the weighted arithmetic mean, equivalent to dividing the sum of value times weight by the sum of weights. For hourly fishing rates, weighting by time is equivalent to adding the coins from all runs and dividing by their total elapsed hours. ## Limits - Use one unit for all values and one common unit for all weights. - The calculator accepts up to three rows and requires at least one positive weight. - A pooled rate represents the time actually observed. It can conceal variation between spots or between runs. ## FAQ Q: How does the weighted average calculator work? A: It multiplies each value by its share of the total weight and adds the results. Rates of 4,200 and 1,800 weighted by 10 and 50 minutes give 2,200. Q: What is the difference between an average and a weighted average? A: A simple average gives each row equal influence. A weighted average gives more influence to a row with a larger weight. Q: Do the weights have to add up to 100? A: No. Enter minutes, counts, or other nonnegative weights directly. The calculator divides by their total. Q: How do I ignore the third row? A: Set its weight to zero. The row will contribute neither its value nor its weight. Q: Can a value be negative? A: Yes. A session with a net loss may have a negative hourly rate, while its duration remains nonnegative. Q: Can I mix minutes and hours in the weights? A: Convert them to the same unit first. For example, enter 30 and 90 minutes for runs lasting half an hour and an hour and a half. When should you use a weighted average calculator? Use this free weighted average calculator when rates come from observations of unequal length. A 10-minute run earning 4,200 coins per hour netted 700 coins. A 50-minute run at 1,800 an hour netted 1,500. Together they lasted 60 minutes and earned 2,200 coins. Averaging the hourly rates directly would give 3,000, which treats both time windows as equally long. Choose weights that answer your question Use run length when you want to know how much you earned per hour across the whole observation. Use equal weights when you want the mean of the individual run rates and have a reason to give each run the same influence. Both calculations can be correct for different questions. Keep entries together only if the rates use the same accounting rule for bait, travel, and selling. Start with the Fishing Session Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/fishing-session-calculator/) to calculate the individual rates. Record additional runs without losing their weights To combine more than three trips, reuse a pooled result as a value with its original total weight. For example, if two observations pool to 2,200 coins per hour and lasted 60 minutes, carry them forward as 2,200 with a weight of 60. Add a third run at 1,300 for 30 minutes and the pooled rate becomes 1,900. If you are working from rounded hourly rates and still have the original coin totals, pooling from the raw totals preserves more precision. Use the calculator with your run log The first two defaults are illustrative session rates. They represent 700 net coins over 10 minutes and 1,500 net coins over 50 minutes. Enter each hourly rate beside its time in minutes. The result of 2,200 coins per hour agrees with adding the 2,200 net coins and dividing by one combined hour. A simple mean of the two hourly rates would give 3,000. An unusually profitable short run would get the same influence as a run five times longer. Start from the fishing run log (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fishing-run-log/) to compare pooled rates separately for a baseline rod and its trial replacement. --- # Fishing Session Calculator https://fishforsecretanimals.org/fishing-session-calculator/ Enter your sales, costs, and time to see the net coins you kept and compare your fishing runs by the hour. ## How to use it 1. Record the proceeds from selling catches made during your timed run. 2. Add the costs you want counted, such as bait used during the run. 3. Enter elapsed minutes and compare the net total with the hourly pace. ## Examples - Twenty minutes with bait costs: Sale proceeds = 1200, Session costs = 200, Session length = 20 → Net coins per hour: 3,000; Net coins kept: 1,000 - Break-even trip: Sale proceeds = 250, Session costs = 250, Session length = 15 → Net coins per hour: 0; Net coins kept: 0 - Short session with no sales: Sale proceeds = 0, Session costs = 40, Session length = 10 → Net coins per hour: -240; Net coins kept: -40 ## Method Net coins equal your sale proceeds minus your session costs. Divide net coins by elapsed minutes and multiply by 60 minutes per hour to express the measured pace per hour. The calculation uses arithmetic and the standard conversion from minutes to hours. ## Limits - An hourly pace extrapolates one recorded session and cannot predict future catches. - Unsold catches are excluded until their sale proceeds are known. ## FAQ Q: How does the fishing session calculator work? A: Enter sale proceeds, session costs, and elapsed minutes. It calculates net coins and scales that measured result to one hour. Q: Should I include the cost of bait? A: Include bait used during the run when comparing net earnings. Apply the same accounting rule to every run you compare. Q: Should I count my rod purchase? A: Count it if you want the total impact of that purchase on this run. Leave it out when comparing the repeatable pace of two existing setups. Q: What if I earned fewer coins than I spent? A: The tool displays a negative net result. That shows how much the session cost you after sale proceeds. Q: Do I include travel and selling time? A: Include both for an end-to-end rate. For a casting-only comparison, track the same shorter time window for both setups. Q: Does the tool use official fish prices? A: It uses the sale proceeds you enter from your run. Prices and catches do not need to be looked up for the calculation. Compare your own fishing runs Pick two sessions that answer a specific question, such as whether a different area earns more coins once you count travel and bait. Start your timer at the same point in each run and write down actual sale proceeds. If you sold items you caught in an earlier session, separate those proceeds before entering the total. For example, 1,200 coins in sales and 200 in bait costs leave 1,000 coins over 20 minutes, which is a 3,000-coin hourly pace. A much shorter run with one unusually valuable catch can produce a higher figure. Record several runs and divide their combined net earnings by their combined duration to see how the setups compare over more playing time. Compare a ten-minute run with a fifty-minute run A ten-minute run that nets 700 coins comes out to 4,200 coins per hour. A fifty-minute run that nets 1,500 coins comes out to 1,800 coins per hour. To summarize both runs, enter the combined sale proceeds, combined costs, and 60 total minutes. The result is 2,200 coins per hour across the full hour played. Averaging the two separate rates gives 3,000 and gives the short run too much weight. Use the Weighted Average Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/weighted-average-calculator/) when your notes contain the hourly rates and elapsed minutes for each run rather than the separate sale totals. Keep upgrade costs consistent If you buy a rod during a session, save its price alongside your run notes. Include it in costs when checking the immediate change to your coin balance. For a repeatable earnings comparison, enter only the costs that recur each run and compare the rod price separately. Set a cost to zero explicitly when you had no expense. A zero-sales run with 40 coins in costs and 10 minutes of play returns −40 net coins and −240 net coins per hour. --- # Savings Goal Calculator https://fishforsecretanimals.org/savings-goal-calculator/ Enter your coin goal, saved balance, and hourly earnings to see how much more you need and estimate the time left. ## How to use it 1. Set your target to the balance you want before buying the upgrade. 2. Enter coins you already have available for that target. 3. Use the net hourly rate you measured after recurring expenses. 4. Read the remaining coins and estimated play time. ## Examples - Save for a 10,000-coin upgrade: Target balance = 10000, Coins already saved = 2500, Net hourly earnings = 1500 → Estimated fishing time: 5 h; Coins still needed: 7,500 coins; How to read this result: Coins still needed divided by net coins per hour. - Already at the goal: Target balance = 8000, Coins already saved = 8500, Net hourly earnings = 0 → Estimated fishing time: 0 h; Coins still needed: 0 coins; How to read this result: Your current balance already covers the goal. - No progress at zero earnings: Target balance = 5000, Coins already saved = 2000, Net hourly earnings = 0 → Estimated fishing time: ; Coins still needed: 3,000 coins; How to read this result: A positive hourly rate is needed to reach this goal. ## Method Subtract the saved balance from the target and report zero remaining when the balance covers the goal. Divide the remaining coins by net coins per hour to get hours. The units follow directly from dividing coins by coins per hour. A target already reached takes zero more hours. When coins are still needed and the rate is zero, there is no finite time estimate. ## Limits - The estimate assumes the rate stays steady and that you set aside all net earnings for the goal. - Unplanned purchases and changes in the upgrade price require new inputs. ## FAQ Q: How does the savings goal calculator work? A: It subtracts your saved coins from your goal and divides the shortfall by your net hourly earnings. A 7,500-coin shortfall at 1,500 coins per hour takes five hours. Q: How many more coins do I need for an upgrade? A: Subtract the coins you can spend from the cost of the upgrade. If you want to keep a reserve after buying it, add the reserve to your target first. Q: What if I have already saved enough? A: The remaining amount and time both show zero. Your balance already covers the target. Q: What happens if I earn zero coins per hour? A: There is no time estimate for an unfinished goal at a zero rate. The page still shows the coin shortfall. Q: Should I enter gross sales or net coins per hour? A: Use net coins per hour after recurring expenses, because that is the rate at which your available balance grows. Q: Can I estimate a goal with an uneven income rate? A: Use several comparable runs to estimate a net hourly rate, then try a slower rate to see how a less productive session would change the plan. How much longer do you need to fish? The free savings goal calculator turns a target balance into an estimate of playing time using three numbers from your own plan. Use a price you see in the game. Enter your available balance and a net rate from the Fishing Session Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/fishing-session-calculator/). The result is time spent earning at that rate, so a five-hour estimate can be split across multiple days. Keep spending money separate from the goal Suppose a rod costs 9,000 coins and you want 600 left for bait after buying it. Use 9,600 as the goal. If you have 7,800 on hand, you still need 1,800. At 1,200 net coins per hour, allow 1.5 hours, or 90 minutes. If you already entered the 600-coin reserve in your target, use the full current balance. Subtracting that reserve from your balance too would count it twice. Check a slow run alongside a typical one Saving another 3,600 coins takes two hours at 1,800 an hour and three hours at 1,200 an hour. Try both rates before deciding whether the purchase fits one play session. If you track several trips, divide their total net coins by their combined time to get the rate. A short trip with one large sale can skew a simple average of the trip rates. If your measured net earnings are negative, there is no growing balance to extrapolate. First find a profitable setup, or enter zero to see the shortfall with no time estimate. --- # Fish for Secret Animals Beginner Guide https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-beginner-guide/ Start with your first catch in Fish for Secret Animals, sell your haul, then compare a second run before spending your coins. How do you play Fish for Secret Animals? Fish for Secret Animals is Chill Shark's Roblox fishing experience. The developer describes a loop of fishing across biomes, selling catches, and putting the proceeds into gear and Luck upgrades. The listing also identifies it as the experience formerly called Catch Rare Fish. Play Fish for Secret Animals on Roblox (https://www.roblox.com/games/107192230357786/Fish-for-Secret-Animals). Start in an area your character can already access. Follow the cast prompt in your version of the game, see what counts as a landed catch, then go through one full sale before buying anything. Keep that first setup intact long enough to record a baseline. Once you have it, you can test one change at a time and see whether you spend less time, earn more coins, or get more attempts at a particular catch. Which badges can you look for? The published badge descriptions give you several in-game milestones. The first two to watch after joining are First Catch and Perfect Cast. Their descriptions confirm separate achievements for landing a first Sea Beast and executing a perfect cast. Explore the timing prompt in the game to see how the cast behaves on your device. | Milestone | What Roblox lists | | --- | --- | | Welcome (https://www.roblox.com/badges/2961594057362938/Welcome) | Joined the experience for the first time | | First Catch (https://www.roblox.com/badges/1741237789221477/First-Catch) | Caught a first Sea Beast | | Perfect Cast (https://www.roblox.com/badges/2208535255768864/Perfect-Cast) | Landed a perfect cast | | Mythic Catch (https://www.roblox.com/badges/3251202778382911/Mythic-Catch) | Caught a Mythic Sea Beast | | Secret Catch (https://www.roblox.com/badges/377429947809101/Secret-Catch) | Caught a Secret Sea Beast | The badge names give you a useful progression checklist, while the public descriptions give no numerical catch rates. Treat a perfect cast as a milestone you can practice. Use the current in-game explanation for any claim about its effect on a particular catch. Measure the first two fishing runs Choose what you want to measure. If the question is how many coins you can earn in a typical play session, start the timer before travel and stop after selling. If the question is how a spot feels while you are already there, time from the first cast through the last cast. Use one timing rule for both observations. Keep catches from earlier trips out of the sale total or log the mixed sale as one combined observation. - First run: Record the biome, the setup, the time, and sale proceeds from the catches you made during that run. - Second run: Keep the timing rule and equipment the same. Change one thing, such as the fishing area, and record the same figures. - Compare: Subtract any recurring costs before comparing hourly earnings. Note any unusual catch that accounted for much of one sale. Here is a practice run using sample values. With 1,200 in sales and 200 in recurring costs over 20 minutes, the net total is 1,000 coins and the measured pace is 3,000 coins per hour. Open those inputs in the Fishing Session Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/fishing-session-calculator/?sales=1200&costs=200&minutes=20). If the sessions have very different lengths, use the Weighted Average Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/weighted-average-calculator/) with their respective times to combine the rates. Decide what to buy first If a rod is out of reach, put its displayed price and your available balance into the Savings Goal Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/savings-goal-calculator/). For a player trying to reduce waiting or earn coins faster, the rod guide (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-rods/) explains how to time comparable runs. Use the bait guide (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-bait/) when you want to test a consumable or target a rare catch with a fixed number of attempts. Check the Chill Shark community (https://www.roblox.com/communities/340532193/Chill-Shark) when the game changes. Record the area and gear alongside your measurements so a run from before an update stays identifiable. What should you write down after your first sale? Write down a line for the first attempt even if the sale amount is small. Put the place, time window, visible setup and total sold on the line. The game lists First Catch and Perfect Cast as separate badges, so track whether you landed a catch separately from whether a cast was marked perfect. Treat an event or a visible change in Luck as a note about the session. Start a fresh entry if that condition changes halfway through. Check a paper example before recording the real trip. If your 20-minute practice run sold for 1,200 and consumed 200, its net is 1,000. In a second fictional 30-minute run with 1,800 in sales and 300 in expenses, the net is 1,500. Both runs match at 3,000 coins per hour. Putting the two sale totals side by side might otherwise make the second spot look more productive. Open the fishing run log (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fishing-run-log/) for a spreadsheet and an example where one unusual sale changes the result. Before the second play session, decide what result would be enough to justify changing gear or location. If the next spot takes longer to reach, use full-trip time and write the extra travel in the notes. If the goal is to practice the timing that earns Perfect Cast, track attempts in a fixed window and compare that count separately from proceeds. That gives you feedback even when a short run happens to produce few valuable catches. Q: How do I start playing Fish for Secret Animals? A: Open the Chill Shark experience on Roblox and follow the in-game casting prompts at an accessible fishing spot. After a catch, learn the sale flow and record your starting setup. Q: Was Fish for Secret Animals called Catch Rare Fish? A: Yes. Chill Shark identifies Catch Rare Fish as the previous name on the current Roblox listing, which uses place ID 107192230357786. Q: What does the First Catch badge mean? A: Roblox lists First Catch as the badge for catching your first Sea Beast. Perfect Cast is a separate badge for landing a perfect cast. Q: Should I change biomes as soon as I can? A: Finish a baseline run in an accessible biome first. Compare the next biome using the same equipment and record any extra travel time. Q: What should I track on my first run? A: Write down your biome, setup, minutes played, catch sale proceeds, and recurring costs. Use that record to compare another run under similar conditions. Q: What can I buy with the coins from my first catches? A: Consult the in-game upgrade panel for the current options and prices. The developer describes gear upgrades and Luck boosts on the Roblox listing. --- # Fish for Secret Animals Rods Guide https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-rods/ Compare rods in Fish for Secret Animals by timing equal runs, checking net earnings, and estimating how long an upgrade takes to pay back. What should you look for when choosing a rod? In Fish for Secret Animals, choose a rod around the part of your fishing run you want to improve. Chill Shark's Roblox listing (https://www.roblox.com/games/107192230357786/Fish-for-Secret-Animals) confirms fishing across biomes, selling catches, and upgrading gear and Luck. Use the rod offer you see inside the game for its specific price, requirements, and descriptions. The public listing provides the overview, while the in-game offer is the reference for a purchase. Write down the name exactly as displayed. If the offer describes a change to casting speed, measure attempts over a fixed amount of time. If it describes better results, tally both the sale total and the number of successful catches. If two rods claim different effects, choose the measure that fits what you want to do next. | Your goal | Record during the trial | Check before buying | | --- | --- | --- | | Afford another upgrade sooner | Net coins per hour after bait | Upfront price and break-even hours | | Spend less time between catches | Attempts and landed catches over the same number of minutes | Whether the increase remains after selling and travel | | Pursue a particular catch | Eligible casts in the same biome and conditions | Any requirement shown for the catch or equipment | How do you run a fair rod comparison? Start with your current rod or gear, one accessible biome, and a set time window. Repeat the same run with the comparison rod when you have access to it. Use the same bait, Luck conditions, and timing rule. A change of biome or temporary bonus belongs in the trip notes. A paired comparison tells you more if the only planned change is the rod. Record attempts as well as catches. Suppose two ten-minute samples yielded 20 and 25 eligible attempts. The second run offered more attempts in that sample. To see whether it paid more, sell the catches and compare net proceeds after recurring costs. A rare high-value catch can dominate a single run, so repeat the comparison before treating a large change as the usual outcome. When does the extra income repay the rod? First enter proceeds, recurring expenses, and time for each rod in the Fishing Session Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/fishing-session-calculator/). Then put the two rates and the purchase price in the Payback Period Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/payback-period-calculator/). It uses the difference between the rates because you could have kept fishing with the original gear. For example, a hypothetical 3,000-coin upgrade and rates of 1,600 and 2,200 coins per hour imply a 600-coin hourly gain and five hours of play to recover the price. At a smaller gain of 300 coins per hour, the same upgrade would take ten hours. Open the five-hour payback example (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/payback-period-calculator/?price=3000&before=1600&after=2200). These are practice figures. Take the actual price from the current offer and the two rates from your trips. What if you have enough coins for the rod but need bait too? Put the upgrade price and the coins you want left over into one target. A 9,000-coin purchase with a 600-coin reserve requires a 9,600-coin balance. At 7,800 coins saved and a net rate of 1,200 an hour, you would need another 90 minutes at that pace. Open that savings example (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/savings-goal-calculator/?goal=9600&balance=7800&rate=1200). For a consumable comparison, see the bait selection guide (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-bait/). For your first recorded run, start with the beginner guide (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-beginner-guide/). The Chill Shark community (https://www.roblox.com/communities/340532193/Chill-Shark) is the place to check the developer's public posts when an update changes your options. How much improvement would justify the price? Work backward from how long you expect to keep the gear. An illustrative offer at 3,000 coins needs 750 extra coins per hour if you plan to use it for four hours. That is a comparison target you can estimate before committing to the purchase. Write it next to the price shown in the current game. Put the purchase price in the payback calculator and keep it separate from bait you repeatedly spend while fishing. A practice example shows why time matters. The baseline catches sell for 1,200 in 24 minutes with 120 in recurring costs, giving 2,700 net coins per hour. A trial's sales reach 1,350 over 30 minutes with the same 120 in costs, giving 2,460 per hour. In those fictional runs the trial sold more coins but its hourly result fell by 240. If one test includes travel and the other starts at the water, run a matched pair before drawing the same conclusion. Use the downloadable fishing run log (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fishing-run-log/) to separate cast count from sale proceeds. A rod might let you make more attempts under your current conditions, while your income stays similar if the landed catches sell for less. If the upgrade screen shows an effect but no numeric rate, record its wording and the current game update. A tiny sample can tell you what to test next; it cannot establish an item ranking across all biomes. Q: How do I choose a rod in Fish for Secret Animals? A: Pick the upgrade that helps your current goal. For income, use comparable timed runs and check the increase in net coins per hour against the rod’s price. Q: Which rod should a new player upgrade to first? A: Start with your existing setup and check the available upgrades in the game. Use the cost and displayed effects to decide which upgrade is worth a trial. Q: Do I count a rod purchase as a fishing session cost? A: For repeatable earnings, put the purchase price in the Payback Period Calculator and enter recurring expenses in the fishing run. For a wallet check, count the purchase once when it happens. Q: How long does a 3,000-coin upgrade take to pay back? A: It would take five fishing hours if you measured an extra 600 net coins per hour. Both numbers are examples, so use the actual cost and your measured rates. Q: Can I compare rods in different biomes? A: That compares two complete setups. To isolate the rod effect, use the same biome, bait, timing rule, and other active bonuses. Q: Where can I check a rod’s current price or requirements? A: Read the current in-game offer for its price, unlock requirements, and stated effects. Public Roblox information describes upgrades broadly. --- # Fish for Secret Animals Bait Guide https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-bait/ Choose bait in Fish for Secret Animals by setting a goal, checking the in-game description, and measuring the cost of each run. How do you choose bait in Fish for Secret Animals? Choose bait by the result you want to measure. For coin farming, compare extra sale proceeds with the cost per use. For a particular catch, read the in-game description and note any stated eligible conditions before spending a limited supply. The developer's Roblox description (https://www.roblox.com/games/107192230357786/Fish-for-Secret-Animals) confirms different biomes, rare catches, and Luck upgrades. It gives no universal bait rankings or exact rates. Treat the current inventory description as the reference for the item's effect and conditions. Start with a familiar area and a rod you already use. If your next test combines a new bait, a new biome, and a different rod, it tells you how the three work together. To measure the bait effect by itself, run comparable batches with the same rod and biome and vary the bait alone. How much does each cast cost? Track the number of portions consumed. If a sample pack of 20 uses costs 400 coins, a use costs 20 coins. Six uses cost 120 coins. If gross sales in a 20-minute bait test were 1,500 coins and the only recurring cost was those six uses, net proceeds would be 1,380, or 4,140 per hour. Try the bait example in the Fishing Session Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/fishing-session-calculator/?sales=1500&costs=120&minutes=20). | What happened | Record for this run | Record separately | | --- | --- | --- | | You used part of a purchased pack | The cost of the portions consumed | Any unused portions and their cost | | You used bait you received for free | The uses consumed and zero coin cost for that supply | The future replacement cost if you plan to repeat the setup | | You changed bait midway through | Separate groups of eligible attempts if you recorded the switch | Any other changes in biome, rod, or temporary bonuses | | One valuable catch dominated sales | The full sale and the exceptional catch separately | A second run to see how typical the result was | When can you calculate the chance of a rare catch? Use the Drop Chance Calculator (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/drop-chance-calculator/) once you have a per-attempt probability that applies to the catch and conditions you want. A Luck number or an item label alone gives no catch probability. When no official rate is available, mark the value as a hypothetical example. The official Secret Catch badge (https://www.roblox.com/badges/377429947809101/Secret-Catch) confirms the achievement and describes the catch as rare without giving a numerical rate. For a hypothetical fixed rate of 1%, 20 eligible independent attempts give about an 18.2% chance of at least one catch. A hundred attempts give about 63.4%. Count only the attempts for which the entered rate applies. If the game changes the rate after a miss, or conditions change partway through, the result from a single fixed rate no longer describes that batch. Open the 20-attempt example (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/drop-chance-calculator/?chance=1&attempts=20). How do you decide whether to use the rest of a stack? For net coins, compare the average gain with what the remaining bait would cost to replace. For a rare catch, decide how many eligible attempts you will spend before you start, so one dry run leaves room for another plan. Keep the item name and patch or date beside your records. Check Chill Shark's Roblox community (https://www.roblox.com/communities/340532193/Chill-Shark) and the current inventory panel after an update. See the rod selection guide (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-rods/) before testing a new rod alongside bait. The beginner guide (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-beginner-guide/) shows how to record your first comparison. How much more would bait need to earn? Do the break-even calculation before you spend the whole stack. If the usual setup sells 1,300 coins of catches over 20 minutes and the trial consumes 120 more coins of bait in the same window, the trial needs 1,420 coins in sales to match the usual setup, assuming other costs stay the same. At 1,500 in sales it adds 80 net coins, equivalent to 240 per hour. The practice numbers are separate from the prices displayed in the game. Record the beginning and ending quantities if the item shows them. Compare cost per eligible attempt with the cost per bait unit when those differ. For instance, if you spent six charges over 20 eligible attempts and each charge cost 20 coins, that batch cost six coins per eligible attempt. This is an accounting result; it gives no estimate of the chance of a Secret Catch. Keep an ordinary run alongside the trial. A larger one-off sale can account for more than the entire difference in the two runs. The fishing run log (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fishing-run-log/) has fields for eligible casts, landed catches and the largest sale. Set the trial's budget before starting by deciding how many charges you can spare. When you are comparing coin earnings, use the same timing scope and subtract recurring costs. When you are pursuing a specific catch, record the exact condition and whether the catch appeared rather than using total sales as a substitute for rarity. Q: How do I choose bait in Fish for Secret Animals? A: Read the current in-game bait description and decide whether you are testing coin earnings or looking for a particular catch. Compare with the same rod, biome, and timing. Q: How much of a bait stack should I charge to a run? A: For a repeatable earnings comparison, count the portion you consumed. A 400-coin pack of 20 uses costs 20 coins per use, so six uses cost 120 coins. Q: How do I know if bait increased my earnings? A: Measure a comparable run with your usual setup, then subtract the bait cost from the trial’s extra sale proceeds. Repeat the test if a single rare catch drove the gain. Q: What if bait was free? A: Record zero purchase cost for a wallet comparison and keep a count of the uses consumed. Check the repeat cost separately if you expect to pay for future supplies. Q: Can I enter a Luck bonus in the drop calculator? A: The calculator requires an effective chance per eligible attempt. Enter a Luck multiplier only after you have a verified rule that converts it to a catch probability. Q: Does a 1 percent drop chance guarantee a catch after 100 casts? A: No. At a hypothetical 1% fixed independent rate, 100 eligible attempts give about a 63.4% chance of at least one success. --- # Fishing Run Log for Fish for Secret Animals https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fishing-run-log/ Track sales, bait, cast counts, and trip time in one downloadable log, then compare setups using a worked four-run example. What should go in a fishing run log? The free fishing run log CSV (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/downloads/fishing-run-log.csv) has columns for biome, rod, bait, bonus, time, and sale proceeds. It includes four fictional practice rows with a checkable result. Use the first sheet for your original observations and a second sheet for comparisons. Leave an unknown cell blank and explain the gap in the notes. Enter zero for a cost you know you did not pay. The official Roblox listing (https://www.roblox.com/games/107192230357786/Fish-for-Secret-Animals) describes casting across biomes, selling catches and upgrading gear. Which variables matter depends on what you observe in your version of the game. Record the names as you see them, along with the date and any update label available in the game or developer community (https://www.roblox.com/communities/340532193/Chill-Shark). That gives you enough context to repeat a comparison after an update. Which timing rule should you use? For income planning, start from the same place and stop after selling. The time includes travel, waiting and selling, so the result approximates what you can earn during play. For casting throughput, time only the stretch from the first to the last eligible cast. Use the same rule on each run. Keep the two timing methods in separate comparisons. For each run, write down the proceeds from catches that belong to it. If you sell inventory from several trips together, combine the time and expenses for those trips if they used the same setup. If the trips used different setups, keep the mixed sale in your wallet notes and repeat the comparison with separate sales. That prevents coins from one setup being counted toward the other. How do you plan a four-run comparison? Alternate the setups so they each get a turn early and late. The practice order is baseline, trial, trial, baseline. Each run lasts 20 minutes. Keep the biome, active bonuses and usual bait fixed while comparing a rod. When comparing bait, keep the rod fixed and record how many portions were consumed. If you cannot keep an important condition stable, place both setups in a broader comparison and describe what changed. | Practice run | Setup | Minutes | Sales | Recurring costs | Net | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | A1 | Baseline | 20 | 960 | 60 | 900 | | B1 | Trial | 20 | 1,120 | 60 | 1,060 | | B2 | Trial | 20 | 1,480 | 60 | 1,420 | | A2 | Baseline | 20 | 880 | 60 | 820 | The baseline totals 1,720 net coins in 40 minutes, or 2,580 per hour. The trial totals 2,480 net in 40 minutes, or 3,720 per hour. The difference is 1,140 per hour under these sample conditions. Try the pooled trial inputs (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/fishing-session-calculator/?sales=2600&costs=120&minutes=40) to see the same result. If a future comparison uses different trip lengths, the weighted average tool (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/weighted-average-calculator/) can combine the net hourly rates using minutes as weights. Does one unusual catch change the result? B2 includes a fictional 650-coin sale. Keep its full result in the record, then rerun the comparison with just that sale removed. This sensitivity check reduces trial net proceeds to 1,830 over 40 minutes, or 2,745 per hour. The advantage over the baseline shrinks to 165 per hour. Both results tell you something. The full rate describes what happened in the exercise. The adjusted rate shows how much of the apparent improvement depended on one sale. With a hypothetical purchase price of 3,000 coins, the payback example (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/payback-period-calculator/?price=3000&before=2580&after=3720) gives about 2.63 hours at the full observed difference. At 165 additional coins per hour, the estimate is about 18.18 hours. A player who expects to switch rods again in five hours would draw very different conclusions from those two numbers. Another pair of trips is a better next step when a single sale moves the answer that far. What can the log establish about rare catches? You can record eligible casts and observed catches for a specific setup. A rate estimated from a short run can swing by a lot after a single catch, so keep the attempts and catches together rather than publishing a percentage by itself. When the developer announces a rate, record its source and conditions. If you enter a scenario in the bait guide (https://fishforsecretanimals.org/guides/fish-for-secret-animals-bait/)'s probability example, keep it labeled as a scenario while you collect records. Pool only the runs that used comparable conditions. Q: Is the fishing run log free to download? A: Yes. The CSV is a plain spreadsheet file with four fictional practice rows. Copy a row for each new trip and replace the practice inputs. Q: Are the example numbers measured in the game? A: No. The figures are a worked exercise chosen to make the arithmetic easy to check. Replace them with proceeds, costs and times from your own play. Q: How many runs should I make before choosing a setup? A: There is no universal sample size. Begin with paired runs and add observations when the result changes direction or depends heavily on one unusual catch. Q: Should I include the price of a rod in every trip? A: Record recurring expenses in the trip figures. Enter the purchase price separately when you compare the extra earnings with the one-time upgrade cost. Q: How do I compare runs that lasted different amounts of time? A: Pool net proceeds and elapsed minutes for each setup, then divide pooled net proceeds by total hours. This gives longer runs their appropriate weight. Q: Why record the largest sale separately? A: It lets you recalculate a comparison without the biggest sale as a sensitivity check. Keep both figures so you retain the original result. ---